MI5 Head Warns of Complex Threat From CCP, Autocratic Regimes

MI5 Director General Ken McCallum gave a rare public speech on Oct. 8, shedding light on the biggest national security threats to the UK, which McCallum says have become more complex.

Threats from autocratic regimes—namely Russia, Iran, and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP)—have resulted in a 48 percent increase in state threat investigations, McCallum said.

With each regime, the “repression at home increasingly extends to aggression overseas.”

“They invest heavily in human intelligence capabilities and in advanced cyber operations,” he said. “Their targets include sensitive government information, our technology, our democracy, journalists, and defenders of human rights.”

McCallum said China presents the most complex relationship of the three because while the UK recognizes the CCP as a threat, it wants to maintain business relations with China.

“The UK-China economic relationship supports UK growth, which underpins our security,” he said. “There are also risks to be managed. The choices are complex, and it rightly falls to Ministers to make the big strategic judgements on our relationship with China: where it’s in the UK’s interests to co-operate, and how we do so safely.”

Related Stories

MI5’s role in countering the CCP threat is in disrupting attempts to harm or coerce people, often of Chinese heritage; countering CCP-backed cyberattacks and mass attempts to steal information; and “tackling threats aimed at our democracy,” McCallum said.

Disrupting these operations needs to be coupled with teaching businesses, universities, and other organization on how to engage with China while managing risks, he said.

The UK and EU have a straightforward relationship with other regimes.

After Russia invaded Ukraine, 750 Russian diplomats were expelled from Europe, “the great majority of them spies,” McCallum said, and they continue to deny diplomatic visa applications to Russian spies.

“It’s not flashy, but it works. Kick them out, keep them out,” he said.

MI5 has also detected and disrupted proxies used by Russian intelligence agencies, he said, as they have less professional training and do not have any diplomatic immunity.

With Iran, aggression has increased in the UK as well amid conflict in the Middle East.

Law enforcement has responded to 20 “Iran-backed plots presenting potentially lethal threats to British citizens and UK residents” since January 2022, McCallum said. State actors often use criminal proxies, “from international drug traffickers to low-level crooks.”

This recruitment has similarities to online radicalizers recruiting terrorists, he said.

“We’re encountering more volatile would-be terrorists with only a tenuous grasp of the ideologies they profess to follow,” he said.

They are also less networked, having little to no connection to other terrorists, whereas, in the past, they tended to be associated with particular groups. Today, the actors may have no record, and no terrorist group claims responsibility for particular acts, he said.

There has been a three-fold increase in would-be terrorists under the age of 18, McCallum said, and they now make up 13 percent of those investigated, driven by extreme propaganda online. The online activity of the teen would-be terrorists also makes it easier to track, but sorting talk from real plotters is “an exacting task.”

“It’s hard to overstate the centrality of the online world in enabling today’s threats,” he said.